U.S. SENATE: THE U.N. CONVENTION ON THE RIGHTS OF THE CHILD
Senator Bob Dole (R-KS)
[Page: S3081] Mr. DOLE. Mr. President, on February 16, Ambassador Madeleine Albright
signed the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child . The United States
joined 175 other countries that have signed and/or ratified the Convention
. The next step would be
for the administration to send the Convention
--and a statement of any reservations and
understandings--to the Senate for our advice and consent.
Mr. President, in the past several days, I have received thousands of calls
from all over the country in opposition to this Convention . My office has
not received one call for it. These contacts have raised many serious
problems that need to be examined. They have raised questions about
Articles 13, 14, and 15, which grant children the freedom of speech,
thought, conscience, religion, association, and assembly. Could these
articles be interpreted to limit the ability of parents to decide for
themselves how best to raise their children? Should U.S. citizens be
subject to some sort of international committee that enforces compliance
with Article 28(2) which states: `State Parties shall take all appropriate
measures to ensure that school discipline is administered in a manner
consistent with the child 's human dignity and in conformity with the
present Convention '?
Under Article VI of the Constitution, Senate ratification of this treaty
would make it the supreme law of the land. Would the Convention then
supersede Federal and State laws? What would the effect of the Convention
be on the tenth amendment? Is the Convention merely a symbolic exercise, or
will it actually require the United States to take actions? These are
sincere questions from sincere people. They deserve answers.
Mr. President, I realize the original intent of the Convention was to
protect children from such abuses as forced labor and to improve the
situation for those children in many parts of the world. No doubt about it,
many children around the world face unbearable and unacceptable conditions
every day. And for these children, a properly crafted document could
provide some much needed relief.
However, I also believe we in the United States have made significant
progress in protecting the rights of the child through Federal, State, and
local laws. These laws are better equipped to deal with the varying
challenges posed by the issue of child rights . If there is one thing this
election taught us, it is the need to get excessive government out of
people's lives. This applies to the Federal government, and it certainly
applies to the multilateral, quasi-government that is the U.N.
I don't know the administration's timeable for sending the Convention to
the Senate for advice and consent. When submitted, it will be referred to
the Senate Committee on Foreign Relations--where I am certain it will
receive the careful review it deserves. However, until all the questions
that thousands of Americans have about the Convention are satisfactorily
answered, I will not support ratification of this Convention .
(Senator Dole (R-KS) is Senate Majority Leader)