INVINCIBLE KIDS: Why do some children survive traumatic childhoods unscathed?
Child psychologist Emmy Werner went
looking for trouble in paradise. In Hawaii
nearly 40 years ago, the researcher began
studying the offspring of chronically poor,
alcoholic, abusive and even psychotic
parents to understand how failure was
passed from one generation to the next. But to her surprise, one third of the kids
she studied looked nothing like children headed for disaster. Werner switched
her focus to these "resilient kids," who somehow beat the odds, growing into
emotionally healthy, competent adults. They even appeared to defy the laws of
nature: When Hurricane Iniki flattened Kauai in 1992, leaving nearly 1 in 6
residents homeless, the storm's 160-mph gusts seemed to spare the houses of
Werner's success stories.
Werner's "resilient kids," in their late 30s when Iniki hit, helped create their own
luck. They heeded storm warnings and boarded up their properties. And even if
the squall blew away their roofs or tore down their walls, they were more likely
to have the financial savings and insurance to avoid foreclosure--the fate of many
of Iniki's victims. "There's not a thing you can do personally about being in the
middle of a hurricane," says the University of California--Davis's Werner, "but
[resilient kids] are planners and problem solvers and picker-uppers."
For many of America's children, these are difficult times. One in five lives in
poverty. More than half will spend some of their childhood living apart from one
parent--the result of divorce, death or out-of-wedlock birth. Child abuse, teen
drug use and teen crime are surging. Living in an affluent suburb is no protection:
Suburban kids are almost as likely as those in violent neighborhoods to report
what sociologists call "parental absence"--the lack of a mother and father who
are approachable and attentive, and who set rules and enforce consequences.
In the face of these trends, many social scientists now are suggesting a new way
of looking at kids and their problems: Focus on survivors, not casualties. Don't
abandon kids who fail, but learn from those who succeed.
Such children, researchers find, are not simply born that
way. Though genes play a role, the presence of a
variety of positive influences in a child's environment is
even more crucial; indeed, it can make the difference
between a child who founders and one who thrives.
The implications of such research are profound. The
findings mean that parents, schools, volunteers,
government and others can create a pathway to
resiliency, rather than leaving success to fate or to
hard-wired character traits. Perhaps most important,
the research indicates that the lessons learned from these nearly invincible kids
can teach us how to help all kids--regardless of their circumstances--handle the
inevitable risks and turning points of life. The Search Institute, a
Minneapolis-based children's research group, identified 30 resiliency-building
factors. The more of these "assets" present in a child's environment, the more
likely the child was to avoid school problems, alcohol use, early sexual
experimentation, depression and violent behavior.
Like the factors that contribute to lifelong physical health, those that create
resilience may seem common-sensical, but they have tremendous impact. Locate
a resilient kid and you will also find a caring adult--or several--who has guided
him. Watchful parents, welcoming schools, good peers and extracurricular
activities matter, too, as does teaching kids to care for others and to help out in
their communities.
From thug to Scout. The psychologists who pioneered resiliency theory
focused on inborn character traits that fostered success. An average or higher
IQ was a good predictor. So was innate temperament--a sunny disposition may
attract advocates who can lift a child from risk. But the idea that resiliency can
be molded is relatively recent. It means that an attentive adult can turn a mean
and sullen teenage thug--a kid who would smash in someone's face on a
whim--into an upstanding Boy Scout.
That's the story of Eagle Scout Rudy Gonzalez.
Growing up in Houston's East End barrio, Gonzalez
seemed on a fast track to prison. By the time he was
13, he'd already had encounters with the city's juvenile
justice system--once for banging a classmate's head on
the pavement until blood flowed, once for slugging a
teacher. He slept through classes and fought more often
than he studied. With his drug-using crew, he broke
into warehouses and looted a grocery store. His
brushes with the law only hardened his bad-boy
swagger. "I thought I was macho," says Gonzalez.
"With people I didn't like, [it was], `Don't look at me or I'll beat you up.' "
Many of Gonzalez's friends later joined real gangs. Several met grisly deaths;
others landed in prison for drug dealing and murder. More than a few became
fathers and dropped out of school. Gonzalez joined urban scouting, a new, small
program established by Boy Scouts of America to provide role models for "at
risk" youth. At first glance, Gonzalez's path could hardly seem more different
than that of his peers. But both gangs and Boy Scouts offer similar attractions:
community and a sense of purpose, a hierarchical system of discipline and a
chance to prove loyalty to a group. Gonzalez chose merit badges and service
over gang colors and drive-by shootings.
Now 20, Gonzalez wears crisply pressed khakis and button-down shirts and, in
his sophomore year at Texas A&M, seems well on his way to his goal of
working for a major accounting firm. Why did he succeed when his friends stuck
to crime? Gonzalez's own answer is that his new life is "a miracle." "Probably,
God chose me to do this," he says.
There were identifiable turning points. Scoutmaster John Trevino, a city
policeman, filled Gonzalez's need for a caring adult who believed in him and
could show him a different way to be a man. Gonzalez's own father was shot
and killed in a barroom fight when Rudy was just 6. Fate played a role, too. At
14, using survival skills he'd learned in scouting, Gonzalez saved the life of a
younger boy stuck up to his chin in mud in a nearby bayou. The neighborhood
hero was lauded in the newspaper and got to meet President Bush at the White
House. Slowly, he began to feel the importance of serving his
community--another building block of resiliency. For a Scout project he cleaned
up a barrio cemetery.
Something special. Once his life started to
turn around, Gonzalez felt comfortable
enough to reveal his winning personality and
transcendent smile--qualities that
contributed further to his success. "When I
met him, I wanted to adopt him," says his
high school counselor, Betty Porter.
"There's something about him." She
remembers Gonzalez as a likable and prodigious networker who made daily
visits to her office to tell her about college scholarships--some she didn't even
know about.
A little bit of help--whether an urban scouting program or some other chance to
excel--can go a long way in creating resiliency. And it goes furthest in the most
stressed neighborhoods, says the University of Colorado's Richard Jessor, who
directs a multimillion-dollar resiliency project for the John D. and Catherine T.
MacArthur Foundation. Looking back, Gonzalez agrees. "We were just guys in
the barrio without anything better to do," he says. "We didn't have the YMCA
or Little League, so we hung out, played sports, broke into warehouses and the
school." Adds Harvard University's Katherine Newman: "The good news is that
kids are motivated. They want to make it. The bad news is that there are too
few opportunities."
Resiliency theory brightens the outlook for kids. Mental health experts
traditionally have put the spotlight on children who emerge from bad childhoods
damaged and scarred. But statistics show that many--if not most--children born
into unpromising circumstances thrive, or at least hold their own. Most children
of teen mothers, for example, avoid becoming teen parents themselves. And
though the majority of child abusers were themselves abused as children, most
abused children do not become abusers. Similarly, children of schizophrenics
and children who grew up in refugee camps also tend to defy the odds. And
many Iowa youths whose families lost their farms during the 1980s farm crisis
became high achievers in school.
Living well. A person who has faced childhood adversity and bounced back
may even fare better later in life than someone whose childhood was relatively
easy--or so Werner's recently completed follow-up of the Kauai kids at age 40
suggests. Resilient children in her study reported stronger marriages and better
health than those who enjoyed less stressful origins. Further, none had been on
welfare, and none had been in trouble with the law. Many children of traumatic,
abusive or neglectful childhoods suffer severe consequences, including shifts in
behavior, thinking and physiology that dog them into adulthood (story, Page 71).
But though Werner's resilient kids turned adults tended to marry later, there was
little sign of emotional turmoil. At midlife, these resilient subjects were more
likely to say they were happy and only one third as likely to report mental health
problems.
Can any child become resilient? That remains a matter
of debate. Some kids, researchers say, simply may
face too many risks. And the research can be twisted
to suggest that there are easy answers. "Resiliency
theory assumes that it's all or nothing, that you have it
or you don't," complains Geoffrey Canada, who runs
neighborhood centers for New York's poorest youth.
"But for some people it takes 10,000 gallons of water,
and for some kids it's just a couple of little drops."
In fact, as Canada notes, most resilient kids do not
follow a straight line to success. An example is Raymond Marte, whom Canada
mentored, teaching the youth karate at one of his Rheedlen Centers for Children
and Families. Today, Marte, 21, is a freshman at New York's Bard College. But
only a few years ago, he was just another high school dropout and teenage
father, hanging out with gang friends and roaming the streets with a handgun in
his pocket. "This is choice time," Canada told Marte after five of the boy's
friends were killed in three months. Marte re-enrolled in school, became an
AmeriCorps volunteer and won a college scholarship. Today, when he walks the
streets of his family's gritty Manhattan neighborhood, he is greeted as a hero,
accepting high-fives from friends congratulating the guy who made it out.
Good parenting can trump bad neighborhoods. That parents are the first line in
creating resilient children is no surprise. But University of Pennsylvania
sociologist Frank Furstenberg was surprised to find that adolescents in the city's
most violence-prone, drug-ridden housing projects showed the same resilience
as middle-class adolescents. The expectation was that the worst neighborhoods
would overwhelm families. Inner-city housing projects do present more risk and
fewer opportunities. But good parenting existed in roughly equal proportions in
every neighborhood.
Sherenia Gibbs is the type of dynamo parent who almost single-handedly can
instill resiliency in her children. The single mother moved her three children from
a small town in Illinois to Minneapolis in search of better education and
recreation. Still, the new neighborhood was dangerous, so Gibbs volunteered at
the park where her youngest son, T. J. Williams, played. Today, six years later,
Gibbs runs a city park, where she has started several innovative mentoring
programs. At home, Gibbs sets aside time to spend with T. J., now 14, requires
him to call her at work when he gets home from school or goes out with friends
and follows his schoolwork closely. Indeed, how often teens have dinner with
their family and whether they have a curfew are two of the best predictors of
teen drug use, according to the National Center on Addiction and Substance
Abuse at Columbia University. How often a family attends church--where kids
are exposed to both values and adult mentors--also makes a difference. Says
Gibbs: "The streets will grab your kids and eat them up."
Some resiliency programs study the success
of moms like Gibbs and try to teach such
"authoritative parenting" skills to others.
When a kid has an early brush with the law,
the Oregon Social Learning Center brings
the youth's whole family together to teach
parenting skills. Not only is the training
effective with the offending youth, but
younger brothers and sisters are less likely to get in trouble as well.
Despite the crucial role of parents, few--rich or poor--are as involved in their
children's lives as Gibbs. And a shocking number of parents--25 percent--ignore
or pay little attention to how their children fare in school, according to Temple
University psychology professor Laurence Steinberg. Nearly one third of
students across economic classes say their parents have no idea how they are
doing in school. Further, half the parents Steinberg surveyed did not know their
children's friends, what their kids did after school or where they went at night.
Some schools are testing strategies for what educator Margaret Wang, also at
Temple, calls "educational resilience." One solution: teaching teams, which follow
a student for a few years so the child always has a teacher who knows him well.
In Philadelphia, some inner-city schools have set up "parents' lounges," with free
coffee, to encourage moms and dads to be regular school visitors.
Given the importance of good parenting, kids are at heightened risk when
parents themselves are troubled. But it is a trait of resilient kids that in such
circumstances, they seek out substitute adults. And sometimes they become
substitute adults themselves, playing a parental role for younger siblings. That
was true of Tyrone Weeks. He spent about half his life without his mother as she
went in and out of drug rehabilitation. Sober now for three years, Delores
Weeks maintains a close relationship with her son. But Tyrone was often on his
own, living with his grandmother and, when she died, with his basketball coach,
Tennis Young. Young and Dave Hagan, a neighborhood priest in north
Philadelphia, kept Weeks fed and clothed. But Weeks also became a substitute
parent for his younger brother, Robert, while encouraging his mother in her
struggle with cocaine. Says Weeks, "There were times when I was lost and
didn't want to live anymore."
Like many resilient kids, Weeks possessed another protective factor: a talent.
Basketball, he says, gave him a self-confidence that carried him through the lost
days. Today, Weeks rebounds and blocks shots for the University of
Massachusetts. Obviously, not all kids have Weeks's exceptional ability. But
what seems key is not the level of talent but finding an activity from which they
derive pride and sense of purpose.
Mon Ye credits an outdoor leadership
program with "keeping me out of gang life."
Born in a Cambodian refugee camp, Ye has
lived with an older brother in a crime-ridden
Tacoma, Wash., housing project since his
mother's death a few years ago. Outdoor
adventure never interested him. But then
parks worker LeAnna Waite invited him to join a program at a nearby
recreation center (whose heavy doors are dented with bullet marks from gang
fights). Last year, Ye led a youth climb up Mount Rainier and now plans to go to
college to become a recreation and park supervisor.
It helps to help. Giving kids significant personal responsibility is another way to
build resiliency, whether it's Weeks pulling his family together or Ye supervising
preteens. Some of the best youth programs value both service to others and the
ability to plan and make choices, according to Stanford University's Shirley
Brice Heath. The Food Project--in which kids raise 40,000 pounds of
vegetables for Boston food kitchens--is directed by the young participants,
giving them the chance to both learn and then pass on their knowledge. Older
teens often find such responsibility through military service.
Any program that multiplies contacts between kids and adults who can offer
advice and support is valuable. A recent study of Big Brothers and Big Sisters
found that the nationwide youth-mentoring program cuts drug use and school
absenteeism by half. Most youth interventions are set up to target a specific
problem like violence or teen sex--and often have little impact. Big Brothers and
Big Sisters instead succeeds with classic resiliency promotion: It first creates
supportive adult attention for kids, then expects risky behavior to drop as a
consequence.
The 42,490 residents of St. Louis Park, Minn., know all about such holistic
approaches to creating resiliency. They've made it a citywide cause in the
ethnically diverse suburb of Minneapolis. Children First is the city's call for
residents to think about the ways, big and small, they can help all kids succeed,
from those living in the city's Meadowbrook housing project to residents of
parkside ranch houses. The suburb's largest employer, HealthSystem Minnesota,
runs a free kids' health clinic. (Doctors and staff donate their time.) And one of
the smallest businesses, Steve McCulloch's flower shop, gives away carnations
to kids in the nearby housing project on Mother's Day. Kids even help each
other. Two high school girls started a Tuesday-night baby-sitting service at the
Reformation Lutheran Church. Parents can drop off their kids for three hours.
The cost: $1.
The goal is to make sure kids know that they are valued and that several adults
outside their own family know and care about them. Those adults might include a
police officer volunteering to serve lunch in the school cafeteria line. Or Jill Terry,
one of scores of volunteers who stand at school bus stops on frigid mornings.
Terry breaks up fights, provides forgotten lunch money or reassures a sad-faced
boy about his parents' fighting. The adopt-a-bus-stop program was started by
members of a senior citizens' group concerned about an attempted abduction of
a child on her way to school.
Another volunteer, Kyla Dreier, works in a downtown law firm and mentors
Angie Larson. The 14-year-old has long, open talks with her mother but
sometimes feels more comfortable discussing things with another adult, like
Dreier.
Spreading out. St. Louis Park is the biggest success story of over 100
communities nationwide where the Search Institute is trying to develop support
for childhood resiliency. In a small surburb, it was relatively easy to rally
community leaders. Now Search is trying to take such asset building to larger
cities like Minneapolis and Albuquerque, N.M.
In St. Louis Park, resiliency is built on a shoestring budget. About $60,000 a
year--all raised from donations--covers the part-time staff director and office
expenses. But that's the point, says Children First Coordinator Karen Atkinson.
Fostering resiliency is neither complicated nor costly. It's basic common
sense--even if practiced too rarely in America. And it pays dividends for all kids.
BY JOSEPH P. SHAPIRO WITH DORIAN FRIEDMAN IN NEW YORK,
MICHELE MEYER IN HOUSTON AND MARGARET LOFTUS