REFORMULATION'S ETHICAL ISSUES
Inhalant abuse, a leading killer of Latin American street
children and an invisible drug problem in the U.S., is posing
some complex ethical and safety questions for makers of
commonplace products. Caught in the crossfire is H. B. Fuller,
Inc. (St. Paul, Minn.), whose leather glue, Resistol, has become
so synonymous with inhalant abuse that, in some countries, young
abusers are referred to as resistoleros.
Where the ultimate solution lies is better law enforcement and
education, the child advocacy group, Covenant House (New York,
N.Y.) is pushing for product reformulation as an interim step.
Its Latin American branch, Casa Alianza,
has demanded that Fuller
add the irritant mustard oil to its existing cyclohexane-based
product, until it moves to a water-based formula. The glue was
originally made with toluene, but Casa Alianza
contends that
cyclohexane isn't much better, and plans to launch a class action
lawsuit against Fuller to drive home its point. A wrongful death
suit was filed in Houston last January on behalf of the mother of
one abuser.
Fuller, which is working on a water-based formula, says that
adding the oil will endanger legitimate users. Mustard oil is
metabolized in mammalian cells as allylisothiocyanate, which may
be carcinogenic. Dangers would be magnified in hot, commercial
settings, where people handle gallons of the material, says Rick
Kingston, senior toxicologist with the Minnesota Regional Poison
Control Center (St. Paul).
however, neither the oil nor its metabolite are on the National
Toxicology Program's suspected carcinogen list. Testor Corp.
(Rockford, Ill.) has used mustard oil in its airplane glue since
1968 with no ill effects, says Guy Carynski, director of
regulatory affairs.
Honduras and Guatemala, where Resistol sales are strictly
controlled, now require that solvent-based glues contain mustard
oil. Given the number of legal alternatives available, Fuller
questions what impact this will have. As Kingston puts it,
"Gasoline will always be there."
For subscription or editorial information:
CHEMICAL ENGINEERING
McGraw-Hill Companies
1221 Avenue of the Americas
New York, NY 10019