BRAZIL: STOP THE KILLINGS OF STREET CHILDREN
(Editor's note: While the deadline for this action is past, the letters provide important background information on the situation in Brazil.)
Dear NGO Representative,
On behalf of the International Child Resource Institute (ICRI)
Brazil Project, we would like to request your assistance in a
worldwide effort to stop the killings of street children in
Brazil. The lack of political will to effectively tackle the wide-
spread violence against the children of the poor in Brazil and to
prosecute their assailants is one of the key reasons for the four
daily murders of children and adolescents in that country. We
urge you to voice your concern in this orchestrated effort of the
international community.
The ICRI Brazil Project has prepared the enclosed document in
collaboration with the Brazilian National Movement of Street
Children (MNMMR). At present, hundreds of human and children's
rights groups around the world are being contacted by the Brazil
Project to form a strong network against the impunity of death
squad members in Brazil.
To participate, contact our office either by letter, phone, fax,
or Email to let us know that your organization agrees to endorse
the document. We will need from you complete contact information
(name of organization, contact name, address, phone and fax
numbers). In the end of March, the MNMMR will deliver the
document with the list of endorsing organizations into the hands
of Brazil's newly elected President, Fernando Henrique Cardoso.
Your participation is crucial!
The Brazil Project is a program of the International Child
Resource Institute, headquartered in Berkeley, California. ICRI
is a 14 year-old non-governmental organization with field
representatives in 52 countries, dedicated to the survival and
success of children and their families around the world.
The Brazil Project Program and Awareness Campaign seeks to
inspire, organize, and direct international support to Brazilian
efforts to provide street children with protection, care, and
opportunities.
For further information, please do not hesitate to contact our
office at (510) 644-1000.
Sincerely yours,
Caius Brandao, Project Coordinator
ICRI Brazil Project
Federative Republic of Brazil Fernando Henrique Cardoso President
of Brazil Praca dos Tres Poderes Palacio do Planalto, Third Floor
70160-900 Brasilia-DF Brazil
Dear President Cardoso,
We write to you today both to congratulate you as you initiate
your presidency, and to wish you success in your efforts to lead
Brazil to a better future for all its citizens. But what bring us
together in addressing you is our deep concern for those citizens
of Brazil that comprise its future generations: its children and
adolescents.
Over the last decade a serious movement on behalf of the rights
of children has grown in Brazil, and its achievements have been
impressive. Yet, in spite of these gains, destitute children and
adolescents continue to be murdered with impunity. We urge you to
use full power of your office to end the extra-judicial killings
of children and adolescents in Brazil and to bring to
justice members of death squads and others responsible for these
crimes.
We share the indignation felt by many Brazilians over the
impunity enjoyed by murderers of poor adolescents and children.
Professional killers continue to profit from these crimes and, if
anything, killings of children and adolescents have escalated. We
cite the following statistics:
- According to the Attorney General (Procurador General da
Republica ), 5,644 children between the ages of five and
seventeen were victims of violent deaths in the period between
1988 and 1991.
-According to Rio de Janeiro state government's own statistics,
in 1992, 424 children under the age of 18 were victims of
homicide in Rio de Janeiro. In the first six months of 1993, 298
children were killed in that state.
The Center for the Mobilization of Marginalized Populations
(CEAP) states that the majority of the victims are impoverished
male adolescents of African descent. In addition to being at risk
of homicides, these young Brazilian are frequently humiliated,
tortured, and mutilated at the hands of their assailants.
The wide-spread ideological argument that every poor child is a
'potential criminal' is not only groundless, but also cruel and
deeply prejudicial. A report released by the Rio de Janeiro's
State Parliamentary Commission of Inquiry revealed that 90
percent of the adolescents killed in the State had no previous
police record. Nevertheless, death squads operate in many
Brazilian states. Police officers are frequently accused of
murdering destitute minors, and businessmen are alleged to
contract professional killers to 'clean the streets'. According
to the MNMMR, Marco de Lima, a city official in Novo Hamburgo
from the Party of the Brazilian Democratic Movement (PMDB) went
so far as to declare that "We have to kill when they are still
young, so they do not bother us after they grow up".
The MNMMR and Amnesty International estimate that over 90 percent
of the crimes committed against Brazilian Children and
Adolescents go unpunished. The resulting climate of impunity
subverts the Law and undermines the State's responsibility to
meet out justice. In effect, to ignore these killings is to
condone an unofficial 'death penalty" that victimizes society's
most disadvantaged and vulnerable members: its children and
adolescents.
Sadly, the world at large is witness to the failure of the
Brazilian judicial system and law-enforcement agencies to uphold
national laws designed to protect the human rights of children
and adolescents. We are also aware that the foundation for change
is being prepared by Brazilian society. In the past ten years
civil society has taken many positive steps to curb violence
against the children of the poor. Eager to consolidate the
process of democratization and to avoid social chaos, community
agents, neighborhood associations, the church, minority groups,
unions, and non-governmental organizations have raised children's
issues as national priorities in the political agenda. The plight
of Brazilian street children led to the passage of the landmark
Child and Adolescent Statute, which stands among the world's most
advanced legislation on children's rights. The Statutes aims not
only to guarantee fundamental rights to all Brazilian youth, but
also to promote a new concept of childhood which could become a
model to other nations. This legislation provides excellent tools
which now need to be enacted in practice. We hope your
administration will commit to fully implement the Child and
Adolescent Statute. This bold initiative merits cooperation and
support from the international community. We urge you to use the
full power of you office to guarantee that the Child and
Adolescent Statute, a remarkable document, does not become a dead
letter. With regard to impunity, the Child and Adolescent Statute
states that:
No child or adolescent will be subject to any form of
negligence, discrimination, exploitation, violence,
cruelty, or oppression, and any violation of their
fundamental rights, either by act or omission, will be
punished according to the terms of the law. [Article 5]
While a few of the most egregious massacres of children in Brazil
have generated commendable responses from federal and state
governments, these measures have rarely led to full
investigations or prosecutions, nor have they succeeded in
altering the general fact of impunity that makes such massacres
possible. We call on you to use your authority as President to
reinvigorate efforts to guarantee rights for children. We believe
that leadership at the highest levels of government is necessary
if lasting change is to occur, and the gratuitous murder of
children and adolescents is truly to end.
The following cases represent just a few of the many unresolved
incidents involving the murder of children and adolescents. Their
resolution, however, would represent an important step toward
ending impunity:
Amazonas - 06/24/94, in Manaus, where five adolescents were
massacred (Joel Santos Xavier, 18; Jander da Silva, 15; Antonio
Cleuter Articlinio, 14; and Moises Pereira da Silva, 16). The
governor of Amazonia State, Mr. Gilberto Mestrinho, prohibited
the reporting of this case in the media, which shows the lack of
political will to hold the perpetrators responsible for this
crime.
Roraima - 08/19/93, in Haximu, where three teenage girls and six
children from the Yanomami tribe were massacred by gold-miners.
Their bodies were cut with machetes, and the children were
decapitated.
Alagoas - 01/20/94 to 02/03/94, where seven boys were
assassinated. The State Government insists that their death were
the result of a gang war, but the prosecutor in charge publicly
declared that they were victims of a death squad.
Espirito Santo - where investigations on death-squad activities
have forced the District Attorney assigned to the case to seek
help of the Federal Police. The group allegedly involved in
organizing death squads is the so called "Scuderie Le Cocq",
which is comprised of over 800 members in the state of Espirito
Santo alone.
Rio de Janeiro - 07/26/90, in Acari, where 10 teenagers were
abducted and disappeared (Rozane de Souza Santos; Edson de Souza
Costa; Mallace de Souza Nascimento; Luis Henrique da S. Eusebio;
Antonio Carlos da Silva; Moises dos Santos Cruz; Luis Carlos V.
de Deus; Edmo do Nascimento; Udson de Oliveira; and Cristiane
Souza Costa). The key witness, Edmeia Euzebio, who accused police
officers of being involved in the crime, was subsequently
murdered.
Rio de Janeiro - 07/23/94 when seven sleeping street-children
were massacred in front of the Candelaria church by a death squad
allegedly made up of police officers.
Brasilia-DF - 02/02/93 when the teenager Laercio Xavier was
allegedly assassinated by Sebastiao Curio de Moura, a Reserve
Colonel.
President Cardoso, we wish you great success in your endeavors
for Brazil and for all Brazilians. Yours is a special
opportunity; we sincerely hope that today's children, and their
children, come to recognize and remember your administration ad
the one that truly recognized the value of every child, defending
the right of every child and adolescent to citizenship, and to
life. We are confident that with you leadership such a transformation can
occur. Brazil is at a critical juncture; the challenges are
enormous, yet the need for change has never been greater. We
stand in solidarity with each and every necessary effort toward
that end.
Sincerely yours,
.................if you would like to endorse this letter, please
contact ICRI at (510) 644-1000. Thanks.
Laura Yang, Campaign Coordinator
1810 Hopkins St
Berkeley, CA 94707 USA
Tel (510) 644-1000
Fax (510) 525-4106
Email icri@igc.org
March ..., 1995
- According to the National Movement of Street Children (MNMMR)
and the Brazilian Institute for Social and Economic Analyses
(IBASE), 1,937 children and adolescents were killed during
the period of 1984 to 1989.
Sao Paulo - 06/12/94, in Taboao da Serra, where three adolescents
were executed (Alexandre Lima, 17; Andre Cerqueira, 14; and
Adriano Cerqueira, 12).